Home » Things We Like

Ultimate Sci-Fi Smackdown: “Logan’s Run” vs. “The Island”

14 August 2009 Things We Like 122,076 views 9 CommentsPrint This Post Print This Post Email This Post Email This Post

I’ll preface this commentary by stating that I choose not to recognize the phoney-baloney homophone “SyFy,” even if there now exists a basic cable network by that name. Sci-fi is not the offspring of “syence” and “fyction,” and for as long as the green blood courses through my six hearts, I will never call science fiction “sy-fy,” even if it means we won’t be able to get a few more girls to read it. It’s sci-fi, dawg! Forged by Asimov and Clarke, handed down to Stephenson and Butler! All the nerds in the house say “Grok!”

Over the coming months, I’m going to pit a classic sci-fi movie against a modern “sy-fy” movie in deadly, laser-tipped combat. Matte paintings will slug it out with CGI, rubber masks will slug it out with … even more CGI, and the party won’t stop until one movie stands supreme at the center of the universe. For our first match, Michael Anderson’s 1976 film “Logan’s Run” will battle Michael Bay’s 2005 film “The Island.” In the name of Zardoz, let’s get ready to rumble!


Logan’s Run: A controlled population of pretty young people live in blissful ignorance inside an enclosed city. One day, a man and woman escape to the outside world, and in the process they discover the city’s dark secrets and the truth of their own existence. In the film’s third act, they return to the city and liberate the rest of its inhabitants.

The Island: Um, that thing I just said.

Winner: Tie.


LR: An English stage and film actor with a handsome face and a mellifluous voice, Michael York plays Logan Five as a purring libertine who subdues his enemies with his inborn English politeness. As the film progresses, he yells a bit and even gets his hair mussed.

TI: Scotsman Ewan MacGregor — actor, motorcyclist and Jedi — plays Lincoln Six Echo as an eagerly inquisitive man of action who doesn’t know his friends from his enemies – until, suddenly, he does. (Michael Bay’s films aren’t known for their character development.) In the course of the story, Lincoln is shot at, beaten and even passes tiny robots through his urinary tract. His expression is always scene-appropriate.

Winner: Ewan MacGregor, “The Island.”


LR: The women wear flouncy mini-dresses that look like they were appropriated from the dressing room of a Bay Area fern bar, circa 1975. The men wear black jumpsuits with a fat gray stripe across the breast; they’re so basic that anyone with a seventh-grade education in home economics can sew one up for a cosplay event in less than a day. The producers of “Logan’s Run” were so taken with the film’s costumes that they invited Bill Thomas — who would go on to design the bland jumpsuits and Nehru jackets for Disney’s “The Black Hole” — to provide commentary for the “Logan’s Run” DVD.

TI: Nearly everyone in “The Island” wears white unisex jumpsuits with black accents. Designer Deborah Lynn Scott, an Oscar-winner for “Titanic,” could probably have done better work here if she’d cared. The principals  look as if they’ve wandered in from the set of a yoga DVD.

Winner: “Logan’s Run.”


LR: Logan and his companion, Jessica Six (Jenny Agutter), escape capture by fleeing through “The Love Shop” — a kind of slow-motion Studio 54.

TI: Lincoln and his companion, Jordan Two Delta (Scarlett Johannson), escape capture in a high-speed highway chase that’s punctuated by the bell-like sounds of gigantic train wheels falling off the back of a flatbed truck. Never mind that earlier in the film, the trains of the future are shown to hover on magnetic levitation tracks and have no wheels. Hey, it’s my fault for asking, right?

Winner: “The Island.”


LR: Peter Ustinov, in doddering-old-fool mode. His performance is a graceful and charming triumph of character humor. He’s bringing his A game to a C-minus movie, and he doesn’t mind. Also: Roscoe Lee Browne provides the voice of “Box,” a walking, talking Frigidaire.

TI: Steve Buscemi, in Steve Buscemi-taking-a-action-movie-paycheck mode. He’s played the same pop-eyed dweeb in several such movies — “Armageddon” and “Final Fantasy” among them – and while I’m almost always happy to see Buscemi at work, he really needs to stop taking these scripts and let Jeff Goldblum have a chance.

Winner: Peter Ustinov, “Logan’s Run.”


LR: The late Farrah Fawcett has a small part as Holly, the receptionist at a cosmetic surgery clinic. She gave as credible a performance as one can give under such circumstances, and she looks amazing.

TI: Scarlett Johannson pretty much phones in her performance as Jordan Two Delta. She probably had a head full of Tom Waits songs during shooting. Still, she looks nice.

WINNER: Farrah Fawcett, “Logan’s Run”


LR: The late Richard Jordan plays Francis Seven, Logan’s best friend. He loses his cool when Logan goes rogue. Jordan appears to have a great time in “Logan’s Run,” though he also seems to realize how patently ridiculous the film really is.

TI: Sean Bean is Dr. Merrick, the city administrator. Bean made his name playing calm, refined English villains, and he’s so good at it that he scarcely needs to read the scripts anymore. All he needs to do is say things like “Don’t worry, it’s painless” without losing his bemused smile.



LR: “NO! Don’t go in there! You don’t have to die! No one has to die at 30! You could live! LIVE! Live, and grow old! I’ve seen it! She’s seen it! Life clocks are a lie! Carousel is a lie! THERE IS NO RENEWAL!”

TI: “It – it’s just… all right, Tuesday night is tofu night, and I’m asking myself ‘Who here decided that everyone likes tofu in the first place, and what is tofu anyway?’ And why can’t I have bacon? I line up every morning, and I’m not allowed any bacon for my breakfast. And – and tell me – let’s talk about all the white. Why is everyone wearing white all the time? It’s impossible to keep clean…”

Winner: “Logan’s Run”


LR: To paraphrase Roger Ebert, the performances aren’t directed so much as they’re curated. The visual effects are horrible even for their time. And a good chunk of the movie was shot inside a Houston shopping mall. It’s got a 6.7 rating on the Internet Movie Database, and I think at least a full percentage point of that score can be attributed to Jenny Agutter’s fleeting nude scene.

TI: I don’t care if the action sequences are exciting, the visual effects impeccably executed or if MacGregor has a lifetime of goodwill banked with me thanks to “Trainspotting.” “The Island” is a more-or-less direct ripoff of “Logan’s Run.” Watching “The Island,” you can’t help but think, really? They’re doing this? Really?

Winner, and match champion: “Logan’s Run.” Logan! You renewed!

Tune in next time, when Jack Smight’s 1977 “Damnation Alley” rolls against Roland Emmerich’s 2004 “The Day After Tomorrow.” Are Volkswagen-sized Madagascar hissing cockroaches any match for deadly “super-cooled air?” Who would win in a George Peppard/Dennis Quaid sneer-off? Find out!

Geoff Carter

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (8 votes, average: 5.00 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...


  1. Love it.

    I want to see a “Terminator”/”Demon With a Glass Hand” smackdown.

    Also, if you can take it, a three way smackdown:

    “Last Man On Earth”
    “Omega Man” and
    “I Am Legend”

  2. As a girly girl who loves Science Fiction I have to say it is and always will be SciFi!

  3. Nicely done. Trying to parse the rip-offs in The Island is a nearly endless chore but I think you zeroed in on the main one. The difference boils down to ‘stupid but fun’ and ‘stupid and loud.’

  4. Not sure if you also considered pitting “The Island” against “Clonus,” aka “Parts: The Clonus Horror”, but if not you should. I originally saw “Clonus” on an episode of MST3K (to give you some idea of its quality). Years later while trapped on a flight across the country, I watched “The Island” _without headphones_ and was still stunned to realize I knew the entire movie plot.

    Apparently I am not the only one who thought so. According to the MST3K website:

    Robert S. Fiveson and Myrl A. Schreibman, producers of PARTS: THE CLONUS HORROR (seen in episode 811) filed suit in New York claiming DreamWorks and Warner Bros. cribbed their movie for The Island. In addition to unspecified financial compensation, Fiveson and Schreibman want The Island withdrawn from theaters and any further release barred, reports Daily Variety. The copyright infringement suit lists 90 instances where the movies are identical.

  5. David: Hmm, say I. That’s not a smackdown — that’s a melee. I love it.

    sha: I considered mentioning “Clonus,” but decided against it. That particular smackdown is being judged in the courts; I wanted to give “Logan’s Run” a chance to defend its honor in the court of public opinion. There’s more than enough thematic elements shared by “Island” and “Logan” for the producers of the latter film to make their own legal case — and it’s curious to me that no one has. Not even the IMDb notes the similarities between the two films in its “movie connections.” That said, IMDb doesn’t list the obvious similarities between “The Island” and “Clonus,” either. I smell a conspiracy at work.

    I never saw “Clonus” on MST3K; I’ll have to fix that. I didn’t watch the show all that often post-Joel.

  6. Nice one. Is this what they call “High Concept?”

  7. The pictures you chose kind of give it away. Michael York looks close to ferocious as he fires his ‘sandman special’ off-frame while Jenny Agutter stares in wide-eyed shock. Meanwhile Ewan MacGregor, slightly injured, glances somewhat pensively off-frame while Scarlett Johannson seems to be trying to remember a phone number, or deciding what to have for lunch…

  8. […] and rubber prosthetic limbs will ripped and thus rendered saleable on eBay. In our last bout, “Logan’s Run” trampled flat “The Island”; today, 1977’s “Damnation Alley” takes on 2004’s “The Day After Tomorrow” for […]

  9. Jenny Agutter…is the femme fatale…not Farah. And Jenny is so delectible to this day that Logans Run wins.

    Scarlett is just fine.

    Both movies are a lot of fun to watch.

Have your say!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>